Quote:
Originally Posted by
BoSox
Fuck that dealer asshole, who cares if he has five kids.
Wow Bosox. And a merry Christmas to you too. ;)
I share you overall view and I share your earlier statement that small tokes are never appreciated. I actually had a dealer once say to me, when I toked a couple dollars "Thanks, now i can buy a newspaper". And just as Bosox said the toke whoring has really grown out of control. Any dealer engaging in that should be fired on the spot.
Advantage players and recreational gamblers see tipping through very different spectrums. For recreational gamblers, out having a good time, the dealer is part of the entertainment I guess. Like a dancing monkey. So they tip. I see some players playing red or even light green tipping $5 on every $25 and $50 bet. They are now playing to a 10%-20% disadvantage instead of the normal house edge of half a percent for a decent basic strategy player. There is almost no chance they encounter decent variance and win for that night. They might as well of just mailed a check. But I guess they got whatever entertainment value a grown man or woman dealing cards provided. To go back to the dancing monkey analogy, a dancing monkey and/or the person that trained the monkey is much more worthy of a tip than a dealer IMO.
Unlike Bosox's rather harsh assessment, I feel for the dealer struggling to make a living, just as I feel for a fast food worker or the cashier at CVS that I may stop at on the way home. Not the high school kids, but the middle aged people working those jobs that may be struggling to raise a family. Am I supposed to tip every person I encounter that is struggling to raise a family? To supplement every person I encounter? That is not the way it works. I give to charities of my choosing, I can not afford to give to every low paid worker that I encounter, dealers included. If their pay is insignificant, they have the option to try to find a better job, or go back to school.
Now I do tip a bit at the tables. Lets go by the numbers. My EV (expected win) for any year from blackjack is about 80 grand. I play about 60,000 rounds to get there. That tells you what I make, a little over $1 a round. What would be a good amount for me to tip? $1 a round. I would be tipping $60,000 of my $80,000 expected win as mentioned earlier that still wouldn't be appreciated. What if I said, ok, I'll tip 10% of my expected win. That works out to about $1 every 6 or 7 rounds. Even worse as far as appreciation. Downright contempt. Dealers think a player should tip 25% of their bet, repeatedly. I witness it all the time. And you know what, to earn that just over $1 a round in EV, I have to have a large bet in +counts of several hundred dollars. Try tipping a $1 or $2 when you are betting $400 and see the reaction.
So what I have adopted is I will tip $5 at the conclusion of a decent winning session, which because I play short sessions is 20 minutes or so. Losing session, I tip zero. I mean if every dealer got $5 from every player a couple times and hour, they are doing ok. More than the dancing monkey's should make. ;)
And let me ask this? why does tipping stop at table games? If I am playing a poker machine should I seek out an attendant and tip $1 every round I play? Of course not. So it is accepted that there is an additional hidden fee added on to the house edge expected for table games, but not machine play. Interesting.
In short a dealer is not providing a personalized service to me, no matter how much they want to pretend. Not like a waiter, waitress, bartender, bell hop, delivery person. They just aren't! They are providing a very menial task, dealing the cards. Really a monkey could be taught that job and at some point robots and computers will be the dealers. That has started already. Do you know some of those computerized video blackjack games, the 5 seaters with the video dealers have an option to tip. Give me a break!