I still think you over over-analyzing the whole thing, even after reading your post above.

I think they have a policy for up to five free nights at a time... and that's it.

I would think that if you're some whale they're going to give you all the free nights you want. But you say you are overcomped and your tier points played don't make you a whale.

So honestly... from a guy who already claims to be overcomped... what the heck do you want?????