Irony of the Dice Problem

[redietz]

Does anyone else find it strange that one side of the debate claims that the description of the dice throw must refer to multiple events because it is a "probability" question? And yet, the only way to arrive at the fact that the math (not general usage) definition of "probability" should be assigned is because there are presumed to be multiple throws?

Now I'm from Mayberry, but something seems not quite correct with that.