Originally Posted by redietz View Post

You are ignoring basic conventions of English writing to arrive at your conclusion that this is necessarily about multiple events.
Alright, I'm not at all convinced it is a matter of semantics, but for the sake of it,let's for a moment forget about the original question, shall we?
Here is another question:

"What is the probability of a fair throw of two standard dice showing 2-2 given that at least one of the dice shows 2?"

How do you read this question and what answer does it invoke for the 1/6 supporters?

Plain and simple evading all ambiguities there may be with the OQ.

Go.