Originally Posted by
regnis
The additional facts changed the odds. If the question was there is one die slammed down and the peeker said it was a 2, would you now say the odds that it is a 2 is 1 of 6??
No--it is a 2. 100%. No ifs ands or buts. The second die does not change anything. We have more facts than you are willing to acknowledge. The question is not what were the odds that that die would be a 2. The question relates to the 2 dice that were thrown this one time. We know what one of them is. We have only the other to consider and we all can agree on the odds for that one die.