Originally Posted by Half Smoke View Post
Originally Posted by MaxPen View Post
For weight loss nothing matters except calories consumed.

Originally Posted by monet View Post

Agreed.



absolutely 100% FALSE




there are 300 + pounders in nursing homes who are not given any extra food who don't lose weight
you would think with what the nursing gives them - about 2,000 calories per day that they would lose - you would think that it's not nearly enough calories to maintain a 300+ pound weight
but they don't lose weight - because they're sedentary


it's necessary to be concerned about your metabolism
running or fast walking or aerobics, where you are causing yourself to pant and sweat will increase your metabolism and aid you in losing weight
reducing caloric intake is not enough






unless it is an extreme reduction
and if it is extreme it will be very difficult to keep it up
and very difficult not to revert back to old habits and gain the weight back again



the focus needs to be on both reducing calorie intake and increasing metabolism
foods high in fiber - such as beans and other fresh vegetables make you feel full and can assist in reducing caloric intake
You contradicted yourself in your own post.

Calories are absolutely all that matters. If the fatass in the nursing home has a basal metabolic rate sedentary of 1500 calories and you feed them 2000 per day. Then they will gain a pound of fat per week. If you feed them 1000 then the fatass would lose a pound of fat every week.

It really is that simple.

The first thing a person needs to do is determine their individual BMR. Then construct a diet plan to meet their goals based on that. If that is to restrictive then you need to increase your metabolism thru activity.