I found The Pale Blue Eye fascinating for its atmospheric winter landscapes and its attempt to blend historical drama with mystery, but I agree the satanic ritual felt unnecessary and out of place. It would've been stronger if the focus stayed on Poe and the investigation rather than veering into that territory. As for Christian Bale's character, the twist was well-executed, but it could have been even more impactful with subtle clues planted earlier for a sharper aha! moment.

On a different note, I recently rewatched Inherent Vice. While the story can feel convoluted, I love how it captures the chaotic essence of Southern California in the '70s. Anyone else find themselves comparing it to The Big Lebowski in terms of vibe?