Regnis it is so funny how they tried to deny that 1/6 is the proper answer. The most prominent was "but you don't know which dice is showing a 2." Like that is supposed to matter?

I really think the whole thing stems from:

a. they misunderstood the question
b. they got mixed up with the coin problem and used the methodology for solving the coin problem to solve the dice problem

But the Wizard also got it wrong. How? Did he also misread the question?

By the way, it's not over. There are still those claiming that the answer is 1/11 for the craps table example with one die hidden.

And to all the craps players out there who are not members of the forum: thank you for your emails of support. Please join the forum.