Originally Posted by Alan Mendelson View Post
Arc there is only one answer for the one way the question was asked. I'm afraid the 1/11 crowd has been trying to change the question or they read it wrong. I said this early on. As the question appears and was originally stated the answer is 1/6. Even Once Dear concedes this conditionally.
Alan, Please do not credit me with agreeing in any way shape or form, that I agree with your 1/6 answer to the original question as asked and upon the additional common sense conditions that we agreed. vis-a-vis Assertions that the partner always called out if there was a two and that the partner saw both dice.

I have unconditionally agreed that the probability is 1/6 where you set aside one die as a two and go on to cast just a second die. I don't think anyone ever disagreed to that answer to that different question. ( Except when one member agreed breifly in error and later retracted that agreement)