Originally Posted by Alan Mendelson View Post
Well that settles it because that in effect was the information in the original question.
No it doesn't. it would only 'settle it' if IN FACT "that in effect was the information in the original question."
I and many many others assert quite strongly that
It is not true "that in effect was the information in the original question."

I've all along refused to argue the toss about anything other than the original question.