Originally Posted by RS__ View Post

Had neither of the dice been a 2, what would the peeker have done? Would he have said "At least one of the dice is a 1" (or 3 or 4 or 5 or 6)? Or would he have said nothing and rolled again and again, until at least one of the dice is a 2?
Don't we have enough problems with the original question? Now you want to ask all of these other questions?

The original question said the "peeker" truthfully said at least one of the two dice is a 2. That has led to two years of debate, side bets, and alternative questions that (in one case) the author didn't even understand what he himself wrote.

And you want to know what would the peeker do if there wasn't a 2?

Better idea: ask Arc why he didn't declare his non-W2G wins on his tax return? Ask jbjb if it is okay to draw more than one spade from his pile of six spades? Ask everyone else what 2-1 equals?