For me, the thing is that at least for most of my time on this forum, Redietz presented himself as a 40 year winning sports bettor. A sports handicapper that picked winners at a rate good enough to overcome the vig and be a consistent winner. I found that impressive.
But it turns out he was more of what I call a sports betting "tout". One of those many guys who makes their money selling their picks and "services".
Nothing illegal or anything, just not what I believe he presented himself as. A heck of a lot less impressive to me.
And this calls into question the 57% winners to me. That is a number he used to try to sell his service. I know he has some documentation for different years and contests that he did well (dating back to "the package" he mailed Alan). Well who knows what is cherry picked and what poorer years and contest were left out of this 57% number.
Like I said, if someone could really pick 57% winners consistently, they would be spending their time getting bets in, not trying to figure out how to gain new customers for their tout service.But that is just me.